Who Gets the House in a Wisconsin Divorce?

Separation vs. Divorce: What’s the Difference?

Divorce & Student Loans: What You Need to Know

Divorce & Student Loans: What You Need to Know

If you are considering divorce, it’s important to know that Wisconsin is what’s called a marital property state. That means all income, assets, and debts acquired during your marriage are considered marital property and will most likely be divided equally between you and your soon-to-be-ex spouse. Yes, you read that right: debts are also split equally. Examples of debts include credit card debt, medical debt, outstanding mortgage or vehicle loans, and student loan debt.

Under certain circumstances, the court may rule that income, assets, or debt should not be divided equally due to certain factors like length of marriage, the earring potential of each spouse, each spouse’s contribution to the marriage (example: unpaid childcare), tax consequences, and more. The court will carefully analyze these and other factors to determine the best way to divide all property and, yes, debt.

Divorce & Student Loan Debt

In general, any debt incurred during the duration of a marriage is considered marital debt and the responsibility for paying it off is split equally between the spouses. This includes student loan debt.

However, certain factors can make student loan debt a complex issue to settle in divorce court. Many factors must be taken into account:

  • Are both spouses names on the loan or just one?
  • How much is still owed?
  • How did the education earned as a result of the loan impact the earning potential of the beneficiary?
  • Was the loan used exclusively for tuition and books or for things that benefitted the whole family, like housing costs?
  • Will both spouses have the means to pay off their portion of the debt after the divorce is settled?

Once a settlement has been reached, it’s important to update the loan paperwork to reflect who will be responsible for paying the debt moving forward. Otherwise, the loan company may still be able to call on both spouses to pay towards the debt.

Interesting fact: if one spouse earned their degree while married, the degree itself will likely be factored in as marital property and any increased earning potential acquired as a result of holding the degree used to determine a fair financial settlement.

Caveats to Consider

Student loans generally fall into one of two funding categories: private and federal. Private loans, or those distributed by a private organization, often allow one spouse to release a co-signer from responsibility. Government (or federal) loans usually do not allow this as they often do not ask for a co-signer. So, if you or your spouse hold privately-funded loans, it is possible to reach an agreement outside of divorce court if the primary borrower agrees to release the other from responsibility for the loan.

Another consideration: before 2006, married couples had the option to consolidate federal student debt from each spouse into one, jointly-held loan even if the debt was incurred before marriage. If this is the case for you and your spouse, the court will consider who is named on the consolidated loan rather than the state of each spouse’s debt prior to consolidation.

The Bottom Line

When it comes to divorce and student loans, no two situations are exactly the same. The court will take many factors into account when determining who will be responsible for the debt moving forward. However, it is important to remember that Wisconsin is a marital property state, meaning assets, income, and debt are divided equally between spouses unless extenuating circumstances make equal division inappropriate.

In our experience, here is what we’ve seen: If only one spouse is named on the loan and it is the same spouse who used the loan to access education, it is probable that they will be solely responsible for the debt on the loan. If both spouses’ names are on the loan and both have the means to make the payments, it is likely that responsibility for the debt will be split between the spouses.

The best thing you can do is hire an experienced Milwaukee divorce attorney to help guide you through this complex process. At Ohiku Law, I take the time to get to know my clients so I can make recommendations based on their unique circumstances. My ultimate goal is to make the divorce process as seamless as possible so you can get on with your life. I have extensive experience in marital property law, debt division, divorce, and family court so you can feel confident knowing your interests are protected.

Are you looking for a divorce lawyer in Milwaukee? Give Ohiku Law a call today to get started.

When is alimony awarded in divorce?

When is alimony awarded in divorce?

When is alimony awarded in divorce?

Divorce happens every day in Wisconsin and people may decide to end their marriage for many different reasons. However, some people who would like to end their marriage may feel they are unable to due to financial constraints. Particularly in cases where one partner is financially dependent on the other, it may feel like divorce is simply not an option.

In the State of Wisconsin, people seeking a divorce but concerned about finances may request alimony when going to court. This request can be made regardless of the reason for ending the marriage.

What is alimony? 

Alimony – sometimes referred to as “spousal maintenance” – is a court-ordered payment system wherein one former spouse in a divorced couple receives ongoing financial support from the other as part of the divorce agreement. Alimony is usually awarded in cases where one partner makes a lower income or has no income at all.

Alimony is not meant as a punishment to the paying spouse. Rather, the goal of alimony is to ensure the lesser-earning spouse is supported and can maintain their lifestyle after the divorce is finalized. An example of when alimony may be appropriate is when, during the marriage, one spouse chose to stay home to take care of children rather than continue their career. Alimony is commonly granted with the expectation that the recipient partner will seek career education or training with the goal of eventually becoming financially self-sustaining.

When is alimony awarded in Wisconsin divorces?

In the State of Wisconsin, judges have a lot of freedom in deciding when and where it is appropriate to award alimony. A variety of factors are considered, including:

  • Length of the marriage
  • Physical health of the spouses
  • Age of the spouses
  • How property will be divided in the divorce agreement
  • Education level and potential earning capacity of both spouses, including certifications, training, amount of time spent out of the workforce, and the resources necessary to obtain the necessary skills to reenter the workforce.
  • Parenting responsibilities
  • The ability of the recipient spouse to eventually come financially self-sustaining
  • Whether one spouse financially contributed to the other’s education during the marriage
  • Agreements made between spouses during the marriage
  • Tax considerations

How long does alimony last? 

Once again, the judge has the freedom to decide the appropriate length of time alimony must be paid. Length of marriage is often a factor in this decision. For example, a decades-long marriage where the recipient spouse did not work and is past a reasonable age to go back to school may result in a judgment that orders alimony to be paid for the lifetime of the recipient. In contrast, a shorter marriage where the recipient spouse is in a good position to become financially self-sufficient will likely result in a judgment of short-term alimony payments. In very short-term marriages, it is uncommon to receive an alimony order unless the recipient spouse health issues or is otherwise unable to financially support themselves.

If the paying spouse dies, alimony will be terminated. If the recipient spouse remarries or becomes financially stable, alimony will also likely be terminated. When the paying spouse retires, alimony may be terminated if they have no source of income outside their retirement benefits.

How much are alimony payments? 

Typically, a judge will determine the amount to be paid in alimony according to one of two factors: the total income of both spouses divided in half or the amount required for the recipient spouse to maintain the lifestyle they had during the marriage.

Tax-wise, the recipient spouse must claim and be taxed on alimony payments received. The paying spouse may deduct alimony payments on their taxes and usually can also deduct attorney fees related to alimony.

Considering divorce? Get the legal assistance you need.

Here at Ohiku Law, we are experts in divorce law, custody and placement, dispute resolution, family law, and estate planning. No matter where you are in the divorce process, you will want an experienced divorce attorney on your side to help you navigate the complicated legal considerations. We are proud to serve clients in Milwaukee with expert divorce law and family law services. Give us a call to get started today.

5-things-to-consider-before-filing-for-divorce

5 things to consider before filing for divorce

5 things to consider before filing for divorce

Divorce is a big decision in more ways than one. In my years supporting individuals and families through the divorce process, those who get through the process smoothly have something in common: they’ve thought the decision through thoroughly.

It is estimated that anywhere from 40 to 50% of all marriages end in divorce, with overall numbers declining since 2016. Young adults today tend to wait longer to marry and wait longer before making the decision to divorce. Those who choose to divorce set themselves up for a much smoother experience by hiring an experienced divorce lawyer.

Here are 5 things to consider before filing for divorce:

What is your vision for the divorce process? When you first sit down with your divorce attorney, you will have a conversation about what you can expect from the divorce process. Divorce requires a lot of decisions, paperwork, time, and patience. It can also be an emotional time, particularly if there are children involved. Having this in-depth conversation will help your divorce attorney understand your situation and vision for how you want the process to go, such as your wishes for custody arrangement or division of property. Once your divorce attorney understands your situation and desires, they will be better able to support you through the process.

Do you have the necessary documentation handy? When meeting with your divorce attorney for the first time, be sure to bring your valid marriage certificate. You will also want to outline the reason you are getting divorced, such as abuse or irreconcilable differences, as the attorney will need to prove cause. Your attorney will also help you understand the financial and legal steps you must take before submitting your application for divorce to the courts. While this may seem like an overwhelming process, these steps are made much easier with an experienced divorce lawyer by your side.

What is your ideal child custody arrangement? If you have children and are considering divorce, one of the best choices you can make is to choose to settle your divorce with mediation rather than litigation. When a divorce case goes through litigation, it is the obligation of the judge to decide custody arrangements. In mediation, you, your spouse, and your respective attorneys work together to find a custody solution that is best for everyone – especially the children.

How will your property be divided? The state of Wisconsin is what is known as a “community property state,” which means assets are divided 50/50 in a divorce settlement. When it comes to a home owned as marital property, this can make things complicated. Together with your attorney, you will need to decide if you are willing to sell your half of the house to your spouse, if you want to buy it from them, or if you will both decide to sell. This can be a contentious topic, and your attorney can help you understand your options and navigate this challenge.

Can you afford to get divorced? There’s no way around it: the divorce process can be expensive. In the state of Wisconsin, the average cost of a divorce is around $11,000. Add cost considerations to the other stressful elements of divorce and it can end up becoming quite taxing. Divorces that involve young children and custody disagreements can become even more expensive. Once again, having an experienced, empathetic attorney on your team will help you understand how to manage costs, stress, and all of the decisions you must make.

Are you planning to remarry? If you are planning to remarry shortly after getting divorced, you will want to consider your options when it comes to the length of the divorce process. Often, divorces get tied up in courts when documents aren’t followed on time or are filed with errors. Extensive disagreements between divorcing spouses can also lengthen the process. You may also have options for expediting the divorce process depending on your situation. Your divorce lawyer can help you navigate these situations and understand your options so you can get through the process as seamlessly as possible.
I’m Odalo Ohiku, one of greater Milwaukee’s top divorce attorneys. I am passionate about caring for my clients as whole people, providing strategic legal services that rely heavily on attorney-client collaboration. If you are looking for an experienced divorce law, family law, or general practice attorney in Milwaukee, give Ohiku Law a call today.

separation-vs-divorce-whats-difference

Separation vs. Divorce: What’s the Difference?

Separation vs. Divorce: What’s the Difference?

If you are considering legal separation or divorce, you probably have a lot of questions. The first one might be: what is the difference between a separation and a divorce and which one is right for me?

In a legal separation, a couple is still married but living apart, with a court outlining the rights and duties of the couple on a number of factors (outlined below). With a divorce, the marriage has legally ended. Legal separations are fairly uncommon, but a useful solution for couples looking to work through financial and/or personal issues within the marriage as they consider divorce in the future.

There are many considerations when deciding whether a legal separation or divorce is right for you and your spouse. Here at Ohiku Law, we help people just like you navigate the often complex world of divorce law. Read on to learn more about the differences and similarities between legal separation and divorce and peruse our website for more information.

What is the difference between legal separation and divorce?

There are a number of important differences between legal separation and divorce. The most important difference to understand is that, in a legal separation, the spouses are still married. After a divorce, they are not. Here are some other key differences:

  • Health insurance: if one partner is covered under the other partner’s health insurance, they can continue to be covered even if legally separated. The same is true with other key benefits like social security. After a divorce, spouses can no longer share benefits in this way.
  • Financial/health care decision-making: when legally separated, spouses are still considered next-of-kin and are able to make important decisions on the other’s behalf. Divorced spouses lose this privilege. 
  • Ability to remarry: if legally separate, the spouses are still married and unable to marry someone else. After a divorce, the marriage has been dissolved and both spouses are free to legally marry again.
  • Shared debts and marital property: Wisconsin is what’s known as a “marital property state” meaning all property and debts incurred during the marriage are shared between spouses. Legally separated spouses still share marital property and debts. Divorced spouses resolve these issues while ending the marriage.
  • Property benefits: legally separated spouses will still benefit from the other’s property should their spouse die. After a divorce, spouses do not retain legal rights to the other’s property.
  • Reconciliation: if legally separated, it is possible for spouses to reconcile without having to legally remarry. After a divorce, reconciliation without legal remarriage is impossible.

What similarities exist between legal separation and divorce? 

In both separation and divorce, the court will make decisions on the following elements:

  • Child custody and visitation rights
  • Division of property as appropriate for the spouse’s situation
  • Separation maintenance in relation to child custody and alimony, though with a legal separation these are decided by the court through a “motion pending litigation.”

Trial vs. permanent separation

If you are considering a legal separation, you have a couple of options to choose from depending on your unique situation. Before going through a legal process, you may decide to try what’s called a “trial separation,” an informal arrangement between spouses. Spouses may decide to move forward with legal separation or divorce after a trial separation or may decide to reconcile.

A permanent separation means the spouses have decided to separate permanently. This may mean they decide to file separation paperwork to begin a legal separation or move forward with a divorce. The treatment of property and debt during a trial, permanent, and legal separation can be complex, so consult an experienced divorce lawyer to find out what you need to know.
Whether you are looking into legal separation or divorce, you will want a trusted attorney on your side. I’m Odalo Ohiku and I work hard to set myself apart from traditional family law and divorce attorneys in Milwaukee. The team at Ohiku Law is there when you need us – 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Give us a call today to get started.

Milwaukee divorce and guardianship

Guardians Ad Litem in Family Court – Frequently Asked Questions

Guardians Ad Litem in Family Court – Frequently Asked Questions

Milwaukee divorce and guardianshipDivorce is a complex process made even more challenging when children are involved. If you have children, deciding how to structure your family’s future to best meet their needs is one of the most important decisions you will make in the divorce process. 

Legal custody, physical placement, and child support are the three main elements that will need to be decided upon for children in a divorce proceeding. “Legal custody” describes the responsibility of making major decisions for the children such as education and healthcare. “Physical placement” describes where and with whom the child lives. “Child support” describes the financial support of the child. If you and your partner disagree on one or more of these major elements, you will need to participate in a mediation process to resolve your differences and move forward. 

If you are unable to reach a satisfying decision on these issues even with the help of a mediator, the family court judge may appoint a specialized attorney, known as a “guardian ad litem” (GAL), to assist in the decision-making process. Below are answers to the most frequently asked questions about the role of a GAL. 

What is a guardian ad litem (GAL)?

A GAL is a licensed attorney whose role is to investigate, determine, and represent the best interests of the children involved in a divorce proceeding. 

The responsibilities of a GAL include investigating the ins and outs of the child’s life and experience as part of a family, participating in negotiations and mediation, and advancing a position on major areas of a divorce proceeding that involved children: legal custody, physical placement and, where appropriate, child support. 

The GAL is not the child’s attorney, nor do they fulfill any of the duties of a parent or guardian. Rather, the role of the GAL is to advocate in court on behalf of the best interests of the child. 

Why might a GAL become involved in a divorce case? 

If the parties in a divorce proceeding cannot come to an agreement on major issues affecting children, like physical placement and legal custody, they move to mediation. If they still cannot come to an agreement or mediation is not possible or appropriate in the situation, the court will appoint a GAL. 

A GAL may also be appointed if a judge is concerned about the welfare of the child or children involved in a divorce proceeding. A GAL may be appointed at any time during the case but is usually brought on in the beginning. One situation in which a court may decide not to appoint a GAL is in a modification proceeding where a judge feels this support is unnecessary. 

How is a GAL appointed?

Either the family court commissioner or judge in a divorce case appoints a GAL, and may do so on their own accord or when requested by one of the parents. How the GAL is chosen depends on the law of the county – the GAL is either chosen from a list of attorneys or is specifically contracted by the county to fulfill this duty when necessary. 

What is the role of the GAL? 

The ultimate goal of the GAL is to identify and represent the best interests of the child or children involved in a divorce case. In fulfilling this role, a GAL may be involved in negotiation of settlements, conduct investigations into allegations of abuse or negligence, hire expert consultants, conduct witness interviews, comment on agreements or parenting plans submitted, and engage in court proceedings. 

Either parent in the divorce proceeding can request a status hearing on the work of the GAL. However, this can only happen 120 days after the appointment date. A second hearing can be requested 120 days after the first status hearing. 

Does the GAL meet with the parents and child/children?

Yes. The GAL meets with both parents in their office, usually holding separate meetings with each. The GAL will decide if and when to meet with the child or children and, if they do decide to meet, what location would be most appropriate for the meeting. 

What does a GAL’s investigation into issues that affect the child look like? 

As a divorce attorney in Milwaukee, a GAL only investigates issues that are relevant to the case. Much of the GAL’s investigation falls under the umbrella of “informal discovery,” or interviews with parties involved in or relevant to the case. The GAL may ask for the input of experts such as a psychologist or social worker and may request that the parents sign a release authorizing them to review school and medical records. If one or both parents have issues with alcohol or drugs, a GAL may request that the judge order screening tests. 

Other elements of a GAL’s investigation fall under “formal discovery,” including interrogatories, requesting documents, and conducting depositions.

What factors does a GAL consider in their investigation? 

A GAL considers a number of factors before making a determination and recommendation to the court. Some of these factors may be: the wishes of the parents and child/children; whether there has been abuse or drug or alcohol use that has impacted the child; the safety of all parties involved; the age and developmental needs of the child; the ability of the child to adjust to their living situation, educational situation, and changes in home life; the relationship of the child to their parents and extended family; plans put forward by the parents for supporting and caring for the child; the testimony of experts like social workers and health care professionals; the mental and physical health of the parents; the relationship between the parents and their perceived ability to cooperate in the future on the needs of the child; and many other important factors. 

What happens after a GAL completes their investigation? 

After completing their investigation, the GAL usually gives the parents and attorneys a preliminary summary of what they plan to put in front of the judge. After this preliminary summary, the attorneys and parents meet to discuss the findings and see if they can reach an agreement. If they cannot, the case proceeds to trial before a judge, where the GAL shares their findings and final decision is reached. 

How is the GAL paid? 

The judge in a divorce case decides who will pay for the GAL. Usually, they determine that the parents will split the cost of the GAL. In cases where the judge determines that one or both parents are unable to pay, the county may become responsible for payment. However, in this case, the parents are still responsible for paying any fees and may be required to pay back the county over time. 

Can I request to change GALs? 

Only a judge can remove a GAL from a case and there are very few circumstances in which they would decide to do so. 

How long is a GAL involved in a divorce case? 

Statute dictates that a GAL serves in their role until one of two things happen: either the parents reach a written agreement resolving the relevant issues or the judge makes a decision in the case at a hearing. 

A judge may decide to dismiss a GAL if they decide it is no longer necessary to employ these services. In case of an appeal, the same GAL is involved unless the judge says otherwise. If a new motion is filed, the judge decides whether to appoint the same or a different GAL to represent the interests of the child. 

Understanding Child Custody Law in Wisconsin

Understanding Child Custody Law in Wisconsin

Understanding Child Custody Law in Wisconsin

Ohiku LawUnderstanding Child Custody Law in Wisconsin

The main goal of family courts in the state of Wisconsin is to facilitate the healthiest and safest possible custody arrangement for a child. To this end, courts in Wisconsin aim for joint child custody or an agreeable co-parenting plan wherever possible. However, child custody law in Wisconsin will accommodate both sole and joint legal custody arrangements.

I’m Odalo Ohiku. Here at Ohiku Law, I help Milwaukee families navigate the often complicated world of child custody. Every family’s situation is different and only an experienced attorney can help you come to the best solution for you and your child. Below is a handy guide to understanding child custody law in Wisconsin, but give me a call to discuss further. 

What does “legal custody” mean?

The term “legal custody” refers to the legal right of a parent to make significant decisions about their children. These include decisions about health care, education, religion, and consent to marry or join the military. This term does not cover where a child lives, which is decided separately and is referred to as “physical placement.”

Who will get custody of your child?

The primary objective of family courts in Wisconsin is to find the best custody solution for the child or children. Before going to court, parents should take the opportunity to try and come to an agreement on their own or with the help of attorneys in a mediation process. If these solutions do not work, the child custody case will need to be heard and decided upon in court.

The court considers many factors when deciding custody, including:

  • The age of the child
  • The living situation of each parent
  • The relationship between the child and each parent
  • The preference of the child in regards to living arrangement
  • The mental and bodily health of each parent
  • What arrangement will provide for stability and consistency
  • The willingness of each parent to co-parent cooperatively
  • Past violence or substance abuse

A major part of any child custody arrangement is the creation of a parenting plan. This is an outline of care agreed upon by both parents and becomes legally binding through a court order.

What is the difference between joint and sole child custody?

Joint legal custody gives both parents the right to make major decisions on behalf of and concerning their children. These decisions must be agreed upon with both parents getting an equal say in the final decision. Joint legal custody is the presumed outcome of any custody case unless there are outstanding circumstances, such as a history of violence, or if the parents come to a different agreement.

Sole legal custody gives only one parent the right to make major decisions concerning the child.

Depending on the circumstances, the court may decide that one parent is allowed to make decisions around certain issues, such as education.

How does child custody work if the parents are unmarried?

Custody law in Wisconsin remains the same whether the parents are married or unmarried. Both parents retain equal right to make major decisions about the child unless otherwise ordered by the court.

If child paternity is in question, certain procedures need to be followed to determine custody. The father can sign an acknowledgment of paternity with the agreement of the mother or, if the mother contests paternity, can petition the court for a DNA test.

Child custody law is extremely complex and every family’s situation is different. By seeking the help of an attorney experienced in family law, you can ensure the best custody outcome for you and your child.

Another element of custody law is that it can quickly become heated and emotional – there is just so much at stake. If parents can’t come to an agreement, the court process can become stressful for everyone involved, including the child or children. Having an experienced advocate on your side will make the whole process easier, and I do everything I can to ensure the best interests of the child are met.

At Ohiku Law, my top priority is to be there for my clients. I am proud to serve families in Milwaukee and surrounding communities with expert family law and divorce law services. Don’t spend another day confused or stressed about your situation – give me a call to get started today.

Why hire a divorce attorney in Milwaukee

3 Reasons to Hire a Divorce Lawyer

3 Reasons to Hire a Divorce Lawyer

Why hire a divorce attorney in MilwaukeeEarly in the divorce process, you may be tempted to consider representing yourself in court. One of the biggest reasons people choose to do so is that they think it will save them money, so they overlook some of the significant downsides to foregoing the advice and support of a divorce lawyer

Perhaps you weren’t married for long, or you and your spouse do not have children or significant assets. In certain cases, you may be ok using a kit or online service instead of hiring a lawyer to help you with your divorce. However, the majority of people see big benefits in hiring an experienced divorce attorney. 

Here are 3 reasons why you should hire a divorce lawyer:

  1. Expertise in family court and divorce law. In hiring an attorney experienced in family court and marital law, you benefit from their years of expertise in navigating the often complicated divorce process. Those who represent themselves are held to the same standard as a divorce attorney in court, receiving no special treatment from the judge. In fact, not knowing the law, what documents you need, or what the next steps are in the divorce process will almost certainly cause a judge to lose sympathy and patience for your cause. Even experienced lawyers going through a divorce process hire an attorney if marital law is not their area of expertise.
  2. An objective perspective. Going through a divorce can be extremely emotional, distracting, and disruptive to your normal routine. Added to this emotional stress are the complexity, time, and money that goes into the legal process of getting a divorce. In hiring a divorce lawyer, you gain a team member who can provide an outside, expert perspective, answering your questions, guiding you as you make decisions and set priorities, and providing advice based on their years of experience. Your divorce attorney has your best interests in mind during a time when you may not even be sure what a satisfying solution may look like. The most “successful” divorce cases end in compromise, with both sides agreeing to a solution that may not necessarily be exactly what they were hoping, but is best for everyone involved. An experienced attorney can help you focus on the big picture rather than getting bogged down by every little thing. As a divorce attorney myself, I know that my clients have limited time and money, so I do my very best to move the process along, providing support and an objective, expert perspective along the way.
  3. One word: paperwork. Unless you’ve previously gone through a divorce without hiring a lawyer, it’s hard to imagine the amount of paperwork needed to complete the process. In deciding to represent yourself, you miss out on having an expert at every stage of the divorce process ensure you have the documentation you need. In court, the judge relies heavily on documentation to make their judgment, and not having the right paperwork can hurt your case by making you seem careless or intentionally evasive. An experienced divorce attorney can make sure your paperwork is filled out correctly in a way that makes a persuasive case, better positioning you for a favorable outcome. Finally, not having the right paperwork will slow down the divorce process significantly; in fact, it’s one of the biggest reasons cases get tied up in the courts. 

There are lots of reasons why hiring a divorce lawyer is the right call. In addition to having an expert in marital law and family court on your team, you have someone you can turn to for advice, perspective, and help in seeing the bigger picture. 

You don’t have to go through the divorce process alone; at Ohiku Law, we help clients in Milwaukee and across the region with expert legal advice and services. Divorce is our area of expertise, and we are passionate about ensuring you and your family get through this stressful time as quickly and smoothly as possible. For questions or to get started today, give us a call. mobile notary Jacksonville, Accountant Abbotsford, Lawyers in Yonkers

Some Reflections on Body Cavity Searches at District 5 in Milwaukee

Some Reflections on Body Cavity Searches at District 5 in Milwaukee

Wis. Stat. 968.255 (3) clearly states:  “No person other than a physician, physician assistant or registered nurse licensed to practice in this state may conduct a body cavity search.”

Wis. Stat. 968.225 allows for “strip searches” so long as certain guidelines are followed.  It defines “strip search” as “a search in which a detained person’s genitals, pubic area, buttock or anus, or a detained female person’s breast, is uncovered and either exposed to view or touched by a person conducting the search.”

In State v. Wallace, the Court of Appeals of Wisconsin shed light on the difference between a “strip search” and “body cavity search.”  Regarding the search in that case, it stated the strip search “became a visual body cavity search when the officer had the defendant bend over to expose his anus.”   Additionally, the court noted that since a body cavity search is more intrusive than a strip search, a person’s consent to a strip search does not constitute valid consent to the more intrusive body cavity search.

The U.S. Supreme Court views all searches of a person’s body as highly intrusive invasions of one’s privacy. Addressing only the limited “pat-down” search of a suspect in Terry v. Ohio, the Supreme Court explained that, “even a limited search of the outer clothing for weapons constitutes a severe, though brief, intrusion upon cherished personal security, and it must surely be an annoying, frightening, and perhaps humiliating experience.” Because of their significantly greater degree of intrusiveness, searches such as the one conducted in this case are closely scrutinized when challenged under the Fourth Amendment.

The United States Supreme Court has long deemed searches of any kind an attack on the most sacred of our rights, namely, our personal liberty.  In that vein, I believe it is abundantly clear that our Supreme Court identifies a body cavity search as one of the most intrusivehumiliating, and degrading experiences to which a person can be subjected.  Similarly, the Seventh Circuit has described searches in Mary Beth G. v. City of Chicago “involving the visual inspection of the anal and genital areas as ‘demeaningdehumanizingundignifiedhumiliatingterrifying,unpleasantembarrassing,  repulsivesignifying degradation and submission.’” For these reasons, and fundamental to our free society, it is imperative that we protect all our citizens from illegal body cavity searches by any means necessary within the confines of the law.